mcity

Social Justice Sally: I don't like this attempted rape scene in the new Tomb Raider game! It's excessive!

Me: How do you define "excessive"?

Sally: It's being used as a cheap plot hook!

Me: It's being framed by the developer as a critical plot point in Lara's character development. In fact, he also said that if she doesn't kill her assailant, she dies. So the scene isn't so much about "Lara's almost-rape" as it is about "Lara's almost-rape and murder" as it is about "Lara killing for the first time when faced with mortal peril."

Sally: So?

Me: Aside from the usual assumption that everything involving sexual assault is necessarily about a man sexually assault, don't you Sallies often say that rape isn't depicted enough in the media?

Sally: We don't complain about rape being depicted, we complain about rape being depicted the wrong way.

Me: Do you?

Sally: Yes. Because they're only doing this to create cheap drama.

Me: *facepalm* Okay. Oookay. How would you do better?

Sally: They don't need to show the rape. They could just show Lara after the event, and imply what happened, maybe have the player find clues. This would make for a stronger narrative and a gritter, more hardcore Lara.

Me: So you think the game better is if a woman is almost raped offscreen, kills her attacker in self-defense offscreen, and then no one ever explicitly says anything about it for the duration of the game. You want a sexual assault reduced to a series of collectable plot coupons.

Sally: Yes. They could also use other tropes than sexual assault.

Me: So you want the game to either never explicitly depict or acknowledge sexual assault, or to not have it at all.

Sally: Yes.

Me: And this makes sense to you?